What I’d Like to See More In YA | Guest Post by @DiannaLGunn


5 Things I want to see more of in YA

I’m not the most well read person in the world but I do read somewhere between 20 & 30 books a year, most of them YA. I also interview authors every week on my blog, a great many of them YA authors(although less so recently). And because that obviously isn’t enough of a commitment to books, I also manage a group steampunk blog where we interview authors and review books, a large portion of them YA novels.

The YA novels I’ve read are wildly imaginative, often set in truly fantastical lands with detailed worldbuilding and innovative magic/science systems. But in some ways they are all very much the same, and while I love the archetypes and tropes they use, I want more variety in my reading.

How we achieve that variety is a long, painful conversation about the publishing world I don’t want to have here (and, frankly, I’d rather not have it at all but I’ll have to eventually) so I’m just going to talk about what I’d like to see more of in the YA landscape:

1. LGBTQ characters, especially the T

Far too often I find the only YA books with LGBTQ characters are focused entirely or mostly around the fact that the character is LGBTQ and how they come to peace with their identity. This is an important story that needs to be told, but I’d love to read more crazy adventure stories where the main characters just happen to be LGBTQ. Or stories where there are LGBTQ side characters who impact the story in important ways by doing things other than being LGBTQ.

As a straight writer, I understand shying away from LGBTQ main characters because you’re afraid to get their experience wrong, but I’m pretty confident you can authentically write your character having LGBTQ friends or family. Or even just seeing obviously LBGTQ people out and about. They are out there, especially if you’re writing a story based in our current world.

Oh, and I’ve read all of YA novels about trans main characters, which is a pretty damning statement(if you’ve written a book like this, PLEASE tell me all about it).

2. More positive sex

I’ve read a pretty substantial number(please don’t ask me for exacts) of books which feature characters who get too drunk/high and have sex with people they don’t really like, characters who get pressured into sex and feel bad about it later and characters who have their first sexual experience with abusive jerks. Also, all of the sex in these books is bad and awkward, and I’d say about 80% of it is first time sex and 95% is without a condom.

You probably weren’t a teenager as recently as I was, so let me tell you something: there are teenagers who are actually control of their sexuality, who have taken the time to learn about sex properly and who happen to have good sex. Many teenagers who are eighteen have already been having sex for a few years. And with changing attitudes towards sex and education, I suspect people who are teenagers now by default have better sex than people who were teenagers ten years ago.

Look, I know many teenagers have the other experience, but that story’s been told a thousand times. Let’s give our teenage characters some real confidence and autonomy, folks. They can have positive sexual experiences and still have TONS of other conflict in their lives.

3. Geeky girls who have relationships that start before the end

News flash: I’ve been a geek my whole life, and since I also happened to be relatively attractive, I have never had a problem getting into relationships. And once I’m in the relationship, I can tell you it 100% helps me stay there, since I’ve managed to date almost exclusively geeky men.

I am really tired of the story about the geek who finally finds somebody that appreciates them. I’m also really tired of stories in all genres ending when relationships begin, as if once you’re in a relationship all the adventures end. This is a terrible outlook for young people to have on relationships.

4. Relationships that are actually healthy

Are you tired of hearing me talk about relationships yet? Well too bad, because the romantic relationships in YA are, in my opinion, the stalest part of the entire category. I’m totally down for strong single characters, which happens a lot, but I’m tired of all the YA stories that are about tumultuous first relationships or the quest for a relationship. I want to see actual, real partnerships at least once in a while, because while most teenage couples I’ve known were disastrous I’ve also known other couples with amazing relationships.

This is partially about the sex thing—after all, discussing sex and consent, especially early on, are important parts of healthy relationships—but it’s mostly about them actually being supportive of each other in general.

5. Teenagers from unusual homes

You know what would be cool? More main characters with LGBTQ parents. More characters who come from multi-adult households. Characters who are from some background other than some unidentified type of white, or whose parents are actually from different backgrounds. Characters whose parents follow a religion most people have never heard of.

These families don’t have to play a huge role in the story, though it would be really cool if they did (I think it would be especially cool to see how a kid who grew up in a multi-adult home would deal with their first relationships).  Even having them appear in one scene throughout the book—and of course acknowledging how this situation changes your character’s outlook on life—acknowledges that these families exist.

Meet the Author!


Dianna Gunn is a freelance writer who specializes in helping social enterprises increase their impact on the world. She’s also a fantasy writer working with an editor to self publish her first novel and a book blogger at The Dabbler(http://www.thedabbler.ca) and The Steampunk Cavaliers(http://www.steampunkcavaliers.com).

Are any of these elements in YOUR YA novel? Do you have a favourite YA novel that has some/all of these elements? I want to review books like these. PLEASE let me know about them in the comments below.


28 thoughts on “What I’d Like to See More In YA | Guest Post by @DiannaLGunn

  1. This is a great list, and I couldn’t agree more about more LGBTQ+ characters where their whole identity isn’t based on their sexuality. And yes to positive relationships. I would also like to see relationships where people break up and find new loves. People don’t usually meet one person, fall madly in love, and stay with that person forever. Breaking up and rediscovering love is a part of life, and I often think YA puts too much pressure on finding that one true love.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Honestly, your issues with YA romance are some of the reasons why I actually step away from books that are blatantly about romance. I hate reading a back cover of a book that has ‘girl goes on adventure with mysterious boy who has dark secret’. Seriously? Way to set them up to be in a relationship and, more importantly, why does she need the boy to go an adventure with her? Can’t she go alone? Or like… with a family member or something? I dunno. I’m so sick of cliche relationships in YA and it’s really deterred me from reading a lot of the books out there because while the author categorizes it as scifi or fantasy, it’s actually more romance than anything. *sigh*

    Liked by 1 person

      • Actually, I stray away from contemporary more because of the excessive amount of fluff rather than the cliche romance, because the romance can be found in other genres as well. *cough* Red Queen *cough* Though, contemporary is a prime example of romance… unfortunately. -.- But I have found some good ones: ‘Highly Illogical Behavior’ and ‘If I Stay’ were very good non-cliche contemporaries, in my opinion.


      • True! I actually haven’t read RED QUEEN yet but I’m still going to check it out! Hm, I actually wasn’t a huge fan of IF I STAY but I’m def thinking about HIGHLY ILLOGICAL BEHAVIOR. Thank you for sharing!

        Liked by 1 person

    • I haven’t really found this as much in the genre YA I’ve been reading. In the genre world I think urban fantasy(YA and not) is filled with the largest number of harmful stereotypes, which is definitely part of why I avoid it.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Mm. I think the cliche romance has a lot to do with the genre, but more to do with the author. Since I’ve read plenty of fantasy novels that don’t have it and plenty of fantasy novels that do. So, perhaps you’re picking the good authors from the genre. :p

        I have heard some pretty bad things about urban fantasy and the cliches riddling the genre. However, I think that has a lot to do with the fact that urban fantasy (in my opinion) is a bit of a cheater genre. Authors get you write about magic without having to create whole new worlds for it. :/ Then again, I don’t read much urban fantasy either. So, perhaps I’m severely misunderstanding.

        Liked by 1 person

      • I do think urban fantasy is a lot easier to write because you don’t have to make up an entire world, but if anything I think that means the writers should be working harder to avoid cliches.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Completely agree. However, I think it shows a lot about the writer when they pick urban fantasy, like they want the easy way out or something. I can’t honestly say, though, as I don’t read much urban fantasy.


      • I don’t read a lot of urban fantasy either but I know a lot of authors and very few set out to write a book in a specific genre–that’s just sort of where they end up.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Yes, yes, yes, when it comes to LGBT+ characters. Of course having LGBT+ main characters is amazing, but having LGBT+ characters in any capacity is better than having none at all. Unless we’re talking about portrayals that are purely stereotypes in which case it might have been better if you didn’t include them at all.

    You’re also definitely right that YA needs more trans characters. I’m writing a story now that has LGBT+ characters, including a trans character. I’m not trans, and there’s a chance I could screw something up, but I still think it’s important that I try. One huge help I think for non-LGBT+ authors (or anyone who is LGBT+ but not part of the specific group their character is) is to have people who can read your work and let you know if anything is off or incorrect. Honestly, writing LGBT+ characters can be such a great way for you to grow as a person and learn more about other people, and if you’re not a writer, then reading about them can be too.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’ve actually started seeking out books with trans characters to read because I realized that I literally hadn’t read any. I’d love to beta read your novel when the time comes!

      Having exposure to lots of LGBTQ+ people and relationships has definitely given me the confidence needed to include them in my own writing, although it’ll probably be many years before I actually get comfortable writing a lesbian/bisexual-girls-together sex scene(totally comfortable with gay sex scenes though, probably because I’m actually attracted to boys).


  4. I’ve only read one book with LGBT characters and have just started another. It takes some time getting used to different views of the world, but it’s a good thing for me.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Such a great read and I actually agree with you on all of these points! RE the LGBT I definitely know where you’re coming from! Too often in LGBT books the focus is them accepting themselves, why not have a book that’s past that point and the character is happy with who they are and the story is revolved around some other plot? I’m sure there are books out there like that but I can’t say I have come across many.


    • Glad I’m not the only one longing for some LGBTQ+ characters who have already accepted their sexuality. You might want to follow my blog as I’ll be reviewing some books like that over the next couple of months. Not all of them will be YA but they will all have cool LGBTQ+ characters.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s